All Activity

Minecraft monetization is a spectrum. Some servers sell cosmetics and keep gameplay perfectly fair. Others sell advantages (sometimes openly, sometimes… creatively). At TMS, we’re not here to moralize — we’re here to label servers accurately so players can pick what they want on purpose. This post explains: What TMS classifies as Pay-to-Win (P2W) How our Trust & Safety team applies tags How ongoing enforcement works with 30/60/90 day reviews Our core definition of P2W Pay-to-Win (P2W) means: Spending real money (or paid currency) gives players a meaningful gameplay advantage over non-paying players in outcomes that matter. “Meaningful advantage” includes (but isn’t limited to): PvP / combat power (damage, survivability, better gear/enchants, combat utilities) Progression speed (XP boosts, skill boosts, loot multipliers, faster leveling) Economy advantage (money multipliers, exclusive income sources, better shop/market access) Territory / protection advantage (more claim power, stronger protections, raiding advantages) Access to power-gated content (paid-only items, enchants, bosses, areas, systems) If paying raises your chance to win or skips meaningful grind in a way non-paying players can’t reasonably match, it’s P2W. What is not P2W (safe zone)These are typically Non-P2W-friendly: Cosmetics-only: particles, tags, cosmetics, purely visual pets, emotes, chat colors, decorative items Donation/supporter perks that don’t affect gameplay: supporter badges, Discord perks, queue priority (where applicable) Cosmetic crates where rewards are strictly visual and don’t impact gameplay outcomes The “usually P2W” zone (common offenders)These are generally tagged as P2W or P2W Elements, depending on severity and availability in-game: Crates / keys / lootboxesIf crates can drop gear, enchants, currency, spawners, ranks with power perks, or anything that affects progression/combat/economy — that’s P2W. BoostersXP boosts, skill boosts (mcMMO), loot multipliers, money multipliers. Power commands and bypasses/fly in survival (especially with PvP/economy impact) /heal, /feed, /god, combat-tag bypass Anything that reduces risk or time in a way that affects outcomes Economy and territory advantagesBigger/better shop limits, lower taxes/fees, exclusive sell tools, paid claim strength, paid raid defense/offense advantages The “reasonable parity” rule (how we decide borderline cases)Some perks sit in a grey area. So we use a simple test: If a non-paying player can get the same functional benefit in-game in a reasonable time — without it distorting PvP/economy — it may qualify as Non-P2W. If paying effectively skips the server’s core progression loop or unlocks power that’s not realistically accessible otherwise, it will not be tagged Non-P2W. TMS P2W tags (what you’ll see on listings)We use tags to reflect reality clearly: Non-P2W (Verified) No paid gameplay advantages. Cosmetics/support only. Unverified Not reviewed yet (or insufficient info). P2W Paid advantages clearly affect gameplay outcomes. How Trust & Safety enforces P2W tagsWe treat this like an audit, not a vibes-check. What we reviewPublic store pages and perk descriptions Crate tables / reward lists (when shown) Rank perk lists and command access In-game tests (when needed) Server-owner disclosures and staff responses Community reports with evidence (screenshots/video/links) What we don’t doWe don’t punish servers for monetizing. We don’t “approve” monetization models. We don’t take action based on rumors — evidence only. Outcomes of a reviewTag stays the same Tag is updated (and logged internally) Listing marked Unverified while we collect more info In rare cases: servers misrepresenting monetization may lose “Verified” status until corrected Our 30 / 60 / 90 day review cycleMinecraft servers evolve fast. So our enforcement is ongoing, not one-and-done. 30-day review (new or newly verified)Applied to servers that are: Newly listed with a monetization claim Newly granted Non-P2W (Verified) Goal: confirm nothing changed after the tag went live. 60-day review (risk-based)Applied when we see signals like: Store revamps New seasons/resets New ranks/crates announced A spike in reports (with evidence) Goal: catch mid-cycle monetization shifts. 90-day review (routine)A recurring check for: Verified servers High-traffic listings Servers with prior tag disputes Goal: keep tags accurate over time. Reporting and appeals Player reportsIf you think a tag is wrong, you can report it with: Store link Screenshots/video What was purchased and what advantage it gave Reports without evidence may be logged, but they won’t drive enforcement alone. Server owner appeals / re-reviewsOwners can request a re-review any time — especially after removing P2W elements. We’ll ask for: Store link and full perk list Confirmation of crate tables (if applicable) Anything changed since the last review Transparency: what this system is (and isn’t)This isn’t about “good” or “bad” servers. It’s about honest labels. Some players want P2W. Others avoid it like lava. The point is: you should know what you’re joining before you invest your time. Final noteIf your server is Non-P2W, we’re happy to verify it — but “Non-P2W” has to mean something consistent, or it means nothing.

🧾 SECTION 1: TERMS OF SERVICE (ToS)Your ToS is your legal fortress. It's what users agree to when they sign up, and it better be clear, enforceable, and not just something you stole from a 2012 Minecraft server. ✅ Scope of ServicesWhat to include: Description of what you offer (VPS, shared hosting, domains, email) Limitations (e.g., best-effort uptime, not responsible for external outages) Why it matters: This limits your liability when Karen's Etsy site crashes because her cat stepped on the power button. Clarity up front prevents support headaches and angry PayPal disputes. ✅ Acceptable Use Policy (AUP)What to include: Bans on spam, DDoS, phishing, malware, and illegal content Clear consequences for violating terms (warnings, suspension, termination) Why it matters: You’re legally responsible for what’s hosted on your hardware. A strong AUP protects your IP ranges, your upstream provider relationship, and keeps you off abuse blacklists. ✅ Billing & Refund PolicyWhat to include: Billing cycle, late fees, cancellation terms Clearly defined refund policies (full, partial, none) and eligibility Explain who handles payments (e.g., “via PayPal – we don’t store card data”) Why it matters: Your money flow depends on predictable billing. Without these details, disputes will eat your time, reputation, and profit. Ambiguous refund rules = automatic PayPal losses. ✅ Termination ClauseWhat to include: Under what conditions you can suspend or terminate service Whether content/data is deleted immediately or held for a period Grace period if they forgot to pay (highly recommended) Why it matters: Protects you if someone turns your server into a ransomware farm or just ghosts you on invoices. Also gives you a legal out when you need to drop someone without drama. ✅ ToS Changes ClauseWhat to include: Why it matters: Saying “we can change anything whenever we want” = legally worthless. Without notice, updated terms are unenforceable. Courts have yeeted entire ToSes for this. ALWAYS notify. ✅ Limitation of LiabilityWhat to include: “We are not liable for data loss, outages, or acts of God (like AWS melting down again)” “Max liability is limited to what you paid us in the last 30 days” Why it matters: Keeps you from being sued for someone else’s mistakes, or their unrealistic expectations (like 100% uptime on a $3.50 plan). ✅ Indemnification ClauseWhat to include: “If your use of our service causes us to get sued, fined, or investigated, you’re responsible for covering our losses” Why it matters: It’s your legal parachute. Without this, someone can run a scam site through you and YOU get left holding the legal bag. ✅ Governing Law and Dispute ResolutionWhat to include: The legal jurisdiction (e.g., California law applies) A clear process (e.g., try to resolve things by email first, then small claims court) Why it matters: If someone sues you from another state or country, this clause decides where and how the battle happens. Saves you from chasing them across the globe. 🔐 SECTION 2: PRIVACY POLICYThis is not optional. If you collect any personal data—including email, IP, or payment info—you’re bound by multiple laws, even if you’re a one-person hosting outfit. ✅ Who You AreWhat to include: Legal name, business name, address (or PO Box if you value your sanity), and contact email Why it matters: Transparency is required under GDPR and CCPA. Anonymous policies = noncompliance = fines. ✅ What You CollectWhat to include: Name, email, IPs, server logs, support messages, cookies, payment metadata Why it matters: People deserve to know what you’re collecting—and laws like GDPR say you must disclose it. Vague language like “we collect some info” is a fast track to penalties. ✅ Why You Collect ItWhat to include: “To provide our services,” “to process payments,” “for security and analytics” Why it matters: This ties to the legal basis of processing. If you can’t justify why you're storing something, you shouldn’t have it. End of story. ✅ Legal Basis (GDPR Article 6)What to include: List which of these apply: Consent: For newsletters or cookies Contract: Hosting services Legal Obligation: Tax records, fraud detection Legitimate Interests: Debugging, metrics Why it matters: If you don’t declare a legal basis, you can’t legally process the data. EU auditors won’t find this funny. ✅ User RightsWhat to include: How users can request access, edits, or deletion of their data How to file a complaint How to opt out of marketing Why it matters: Both GDPR and CCPA require this. If you ignore a deletion request, congrats—you’re now noncompliant and potentially open to lawsuits or audits. ✅ Data Retention PolicyWhat to include: “Logs are kept for X days,” “account info is deleted 30 days after cancellation” Why it matters: Helps you manage risk, comply with data minimization laws, and gives customers peace of mind. Holding data “forever” is not legally okay. ✅ Cookie DisclosureWhat to include: What cookies are used (session, auth, analytics) Whether they’re essential or optional Link to opt-out or control panel Why it matters: You need a cookie banner (especially in the EU). Ignoring this is one of the most common GDPR fines, and cookie compliance tools are now expected. ✅ CCPA-Specific StuffWhat to include: “We do not sell your data” (unless you do, in which case… don’t) “Do Not Sell My Info” link Access and deletion instructions Why it matters: The CCPA is like GDPR-lite but still very real. Even if you're not based in California, if you serve Californians, you’re expected to comply. 🔁 SECTION 3: Updating Policies✅ ToS UpdatesAlways show the effective date Send notifications via email, dashboard, or both Give at least 14 days' notice for any material changes Why it matters: Not notifying users makes your changes unenforceable. They could literally sue you under the old terms. ✅ Privacy Policy UpdatesKeep a “last updated” timestamp Notify users if the way you collect or process data changes Optional: changelog for transparency Why it matters: Transparency is legally required. You can’t suddenly decide to use all your logs for ad targeting and hope no one notices. 🧰 SECTION 4: Free Tools & Legal HelpersUse these tools to help you build or audit your documents: 🧾 https://termly.io/ 🧾 https://www.iubenda.com/ 🧾 https://www.privacypolicies.com/ 📚 https://gdpr.eu/ 📚 https://cppa.ca.gov/ 🧠 Final Tips (a.k.a. Don’t Be That Guy)Don’t use ChatGPT or Notepad for your only copy. Version and archive it. Link your ToS and Privacy Policy from every sign-up or payment screen. Don’t screw around with legal language unless you understand it. What sounds “powerful” might be legally useless (or even illegal). Never say “we own your content” unless you’re trying to get flamed in the reviews section of LowEndTalk.